New 3D-Printed 944 Timing Belt Tensioner Tool
- Tom
- Site Admin
- Posts: 8922
- Joined: Fri Jun 25, 2021 2:04 pm
- Location: Silicon Valley, CA
- Has thanked: 932 times
- Been thanked: 3990 times
- Contact:
Definitely 7 ft lbs for the Carpokes tool! The factory 9201 tool spec for a new belt is 4.0 +/0 .3 (so 3.7 to 4.3).
The numbers on the factory 9201 tool are dimensionless. As I wrote in Panorama: "That factory P9201 measures tension on a scale from 0 to 9, but the numbers don't mean anything. They don't translate to any known scale. The gauge could have pictures of zoo animals instead, with the factory spec pegged at half past the bunny rabbit, and it wouldn't make any difference. As a result, even the best tensioning tools in the world are effectively worthless on the 944 without some way to equate their measurements to Porsche's specs."
The Carpokes tool is designed so that, with 7 ft lbs applied, the N arrow will line up with the water pump rail only when the belt has the amount of tension that generates a 4.0 on the P9201. 7 ft lbs was an arbitrary choice -- high enough to be fairly accurate/consistent on most torque wrenches, but not so high as to stress the plastic tool. It could have been any torque value really -- for example, I had an earlier version calibrated at 10 ft lbs -- the only difference was the arrow was smidge further to the right.
The numbers on the factory 9201 tool are dimensionless. As I wrote in Panorama: "That factory P9201 measures tension on a scale from 0 to 9, but the numbers don't mean anything. They don't translate to any known scale. The gauge could have pictures of zoo animals instead, with the factory spec pegged at half past the bunny rabbit, and it wouldn't make any difference. As a result, even the best tensioning tools in the world are effectively worthless on the 944 without some way to equate their measurements to Porsche's specs."
The Carpokes tool is designed so that, with 7 ft lbs applied, the N arrow will line up with the water pump rail only when the belt has the amount of tension that generates a 4.0 on the P9201. 7 ft lbs was an arbitrary choice -- high enough to be fairly accurate/consistent on most torque wrenches, but not so high as to stress the plastic tool. It could have been any torque value really -- for example, I had an earlier version calibrated at 10 ft lbs -- the only difference was the arrow was smidge further to the right.
I believe that would mean the factory P9201 was designed by a politician
Tom wrote: Mon Jan 20, 2025 5:53 pm Definitely 7 ft lbs for the Carpokes tool! The factory 9201 tool spec for a new belt is 4.0 +/0 .3 (so 3.7 to 4.3).
The numbers on the factory 9201 tool are dimensionless. As I wrote in Panorama: "That factory P9201 measures tension on a scale from 0 to 9, but the numbers don't mean anything. They don't translate to any known scale. The gauge could have pictures of zoo animals instead, with the factory spec pegged at half past the bunny rabbit, and it wouldn't make any difference. As a result, even the best tensioning tools in the world are effectively worthless on the 944 without some way to equate their measurements to Porsche's specs."
The Carpokes tool is designed so that, with 7 ft lbs applied, the N arrow will line up with the water pump rail only when the belt has the amount of tension that generates a 4.0 on the P9201. 7 ft lbs was an arbitrary choice -- high enough to be fairly accurate/consistent on most torque wrenches, but not so high as to stress the plastic tool. It could have been any torque value really -- for example, I had an earlier version calibrated at 10 ft lbs -- the only difference was the arrow was smidge further to the right.
-
Speedfrk951
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Tue Feb 11, 2025 10:27 am
- Been thanked: 1 time
I really like this tool and have a upcoming timing belt job on my car that I would like to test this with. Thank you for posting this awesome project. I literally joined this forum upon finding it and will be contributing more as a result. I really like the idea of 3D printing functional or modernized parts of the car. Anyone else making 3D printed drop in parts that are super useful?
-
alexlohrum
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Thu Feb 13, 2025 1:21 am
Hey Tom,
thanks for making this for the community! I´ll print it today to try it out on my early 944.
thanks for making this for the community! I´ll print it today to try it out on my early 944.
